Playing the Global Equity Game

The branding game in private equity and ventue capital isn’t an easy one to win. Can the design function win over the hearts and minds of those responsible for yielding a profit? Stefan and Adriana Liute investigate.

Illustration

The trend towards design becoming an in-house capability at prominent private equity and venture capital (PE/VC) firms is no longer a novelty. Design partners have been brought on board in businesses from stalwart Silicon Valley VC firm Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers (KPCB) to tech mavens Google Ventures and Andreessen Horowitz. The design they now guide or inspire from the inside is of the product or industrial kind. Experiences, software application interfaces, physical objects and services get designed, prototyped, tested and rehashed, often with a human-centric approach also known as ‘design thinking.’ Companies large and small strive to be ‘design-centric.’ They do it so enthusiastically, that there has even been recent talk of ‘d-washing’ – that is, over-doing it with no real benefits, but simply because it is fashionable.

But there are few PE/VC firms who have taken up branding – and often rebranding of their subsidiary businesses – in a similar fashion. Although most institutional investors see branding as highly relevant, few consider it a must-have capability.

Charlie Cannell, digital director at Inflexion Private Equity Partners, one of the UK’s leading independent mid-market private equity houses, has overseen the rebranding of several of Inflexion’s investees. Although all of them were completed with help from specialised branding agencies, in-house knowledge of the field proved handy.

Our investee companies welcome our guidance. Often their teams have not been through a rebranding process before. Rebranding is a significant change for a business and management teams can become distracted from running their core business. Our in-house digital expertise allow our management teams to focus on their business, as we add real value to the rebranding exercise.

Charlie Cannell
Digital Director at Inflexion Private Equity Partners

To Cannell, branding is a tool that helps companies grow by creating customer and employee engagement. He recognises the complex nature of brands and branding, stressing that Inflexion closely looks after all its investees’ brand attributes, from visual and offering-based ones to those that are softer or opinion-led.

All businesses need a brand to face their market, creating an identity and differentiating themselves from competition. Inflexion focuses the impact of digital advances within our businesses, we start thinking about how digital transformation can positively impact the brand and subsequently raise customer and employee engagement.

Charlie Cannell
Digital Director at Inflexion Private Equity Partners

Branding is also instrumental in projecting a business- like image, as good-looking, carefully-designed brand communications are now expected from all B2B companies, he adds. Branding and rebranding is also now part of the new products and services that grow a company’s customer base.

However, Inflexion’s digital director sees no need to acquire in-house branding capabilities for two reasons. First, he says there is no ground-breaking change in the role and importance of branding to B2B companies and to PE/VC firms. It is needed, but not permanently and critically, and not as much as in the case of B2C businesses. The same goes for graphic design, the creative discipline most closely associated with branding. Unlike its contribution to digital user interfaces and experiences, its role in B2B branding has not changed much and is unlikely to do so. Second, he adds, Branding is a necessity-driven service, much like medical care. It is best to source it from specialist suppliers, and not dabble in it too much.

A source with an intimate knowledge of the investment industry in both America and Europe who chose to remain anonymous provided a blunt, yet forbidding, crystal-clear perspective. PE/VC professionals, she says, focus exclusively on growing the value of their investments and on generating profits in the process. They see branding as a service they can procure from specialized providers whenever their investees need it – nothing more, nothing less. Bringing it in-house would only diminish the focus on money-making. Branding is (or should be) a concern for investee founders or managers, who are involved in the day-to-day life of their individual companies, but not to institutional investors, from whose perspective it is a non-topic. She added that branding would never become a key concern to PE/VC professionals, much less an in-house capability at any major institutional investor.

There couldn’t be a starker contrast between this discouraging view and that of Aapo and Miia Bovellan, founding partners, and Gernot Preslmayer, senior partner, at Proxy Ventures, a small, London-based VC firm. To them, branding is a key differentiator and a critical asset to venture capitalists who live in a world where fundraising is so commoditised that just bringing money to the table is far from enough.

All the companies we invest in, we brand them. Branding is a value multiplier, that is why.

Aapo Bovellan
Founding Partner at Proxy Ventures

Proxy Ventures includes a branding studio, and the three take pride in being disruptively different from both typical branding agencies and typical investment institutions. Unlike the Interbrands and Futurebrands of this world, they, “Have skin in the game,” and genuinely care about the success of their branding clients. And unlike the CVCs and Blackstones, they are more deeply (and differently) involved in their investees. They know that branding is a bit of a black box to some of the classic PE/VC firms.

Branding is a hard thing to understand. To some, it is a dark art, which is better left to the specialists

Miia Bovellan
Founding Partner at Proxy Ventures

Proxy Ventures says its second role as a brand consultant is what effectively builds trust with its investees’ founders. A brand gives the firm something to believe in, establishes strong bonds as it is being built and gives Proxy Ventures significant amounts of soft power. Beneficial business decisions are not made by smashing votes during board meetings. Instead, investees make them via brand-led convictions and thinking, often being intrinsically motivated to fight against great odds and save countless match points.

When we work, we build the brand with the company founders. That is part of the VC deal. Many of our founders have great design ethos. We work with them to increase company value.

Gernot Preslmayer
Senior Partner at Proxy Ventures

Because it is built into both the investor and the investee, the Bovellans and Preslmayer believe that this attention to branding is a big value multiplier. So big, that Proxy Ventures only invests in companies in which the brand hasn’t been set up yet, so that they can come in, build it from scratch, and thus reap larger profits on exit.

They share Cannell’s opinion that branding brings value through product-related innovation such as creating new market categories, particularly when it comes to B2C brands. Like Cannell but more enthusiastically so, they also believe branding generates value through its image-building role. A branding-conscious VC firm and its well-branded investees attract co-investors and further investment rounds.

But that way forward may still be a few years from proving itself and hitting the mainstream. Geoff Cook leads the New York office of Base Design, an international network of studios led by creatives.

To Cook, branding is a triple source of economic value and its usefulness is obvious. Brands are major assets when businesses are bought and sold. They generate value as part of the products and services they represent and even shape. And they are powerful networking devices, bringing together the people and the resources needed to accomplish things. He also concurs with Proxy Ventures and Inflexion, saying that branding is more important to B2C businesses who often operate in very competitive environments. But he also sees the traditionally smaller interest in B2B branding as an opportunity.

On the B2B side branding is less developed. As such, there is a very real opportunity for everyone from accounting firms to construction companies to really distance themselves from the pack.

Geoff Cook
Founding Partner at Base New York

Cook recognises that PE/VC firms today don’t commonly regard branding as a key skill they should internalise, but as something that is supplier-furnished whenever a problem occurs. On one hand, institutional investors have conservative internal structures and they are disinclined to change them. On the other, branding is not yet fully understood. Unlike a good team, proper financing or a desirable product, Cook thinks branding has yet to make a compelling business case for itself, because its benefits are less tangible and harder to quantify to PE/VC professionals.

He says these professionals should have a more proactive approach to branding, one that would mean bringing it in- house, and all for a good reason.

PE/VC firms often wait until their portfolio companies have brand issues and then call in the branding agencies to fix them. It would prove more efficient and cost effective to have a dedicated specialist on staff working with the companies to anticipate the challenges and enlist appropriate partners to address the problem areas before they occur.

Geoff Cook
Founding Partner at Base New York

Moreover, Cook is confident branding has a bright future in the world of institutional investment. As a reason for his optimism, he cites a favourable business trend that is discernible from a historical perspective:

If we look at history, the Industrial Revolution began with invention, and cycled through improved engineering, better design and finally branding and advertising. The PE/VC worlds are certainly all about invention and engineering at their core. The VC world in particular is now enraptured with design. It is only a matter of time before they realize that brand can present yet another competitive advantage to their portfolio companies and even in sourcing better deals.

Geoff Cook
Founding Partner at Base New York

The branding industry still has a lot of work to do to convince financiers and entrepreneurs that it can bring serious value to businesses on a sustained basis. Brand consultants have to stress that branding started with graphic design, but that it is no longer limited to it. Branding now brings together many disciplines, from storytelling and industrial design to human resource management and consumer psychology.

The more complex business life gets, the more necessary branding becomes, because it acts as a unifier, a coordinator, a mediator and a simplifier that brings consistency, coherence and, ultimately, business success. This persuasion is not going to happen by just saying something must be done, but by actually doing something. And it is going to take many good serves. A keen interest in branding is not yet the norm among PE/VC firms, but professionals there realize its utility, and they will pick it up sooner or later.

Storience is the branding agency on the side of good brands. Brands for whom commercial success and positive social impact derive from the same business strategy. Founded in 2012 by a team of seasoned professionals, the agency has served over 60 clients and won multiple awards in Europe and the United States. Storience has offices in London and Bucharest.

Share:

Other Articles

Article illustration: Giraffe sitting on bus
April 10, 2017
We Are Hiring
We are recruiting for our Bucharest office. No job requirements for this job. Not before we meet you.
ISHO brand guidelines booklet - article thumbnail
April 3, 2017
Storience was Highly Commended at Transform Awards Europe with ISHO
Branding agency Storience recognised for ”Best naming strategy” with ISHO, the new neighbourhood in Timisoara’s centre.
Adriana Liute
February 14, 2017
Storience repositions itself and specialises in Branding for Good
For branding agency Storience, 2017 starts with a new business strategy and a new brand positioning around Branding for Good.
Illustration: a man with a heart
February 12, 2017
Doing Good as a Competitive Advantage
Companies who design or adjust their business models to pursue both economic gain and social impact are set to win the race. Having this kind of “dual core” is a major avenue for relevant (and lasting) differentiation.
Article thumbnail
October 17, 2016
Open Position: Senior Brand Consultant
We are looking for a Senior Brand Consultant to join and inspire our Bucharest team. This role can lead to agency partnership.
Article thumbnail
August 20, 2016
Brands Face a Game of Thrones
We’re seeing more opportunistic co-operation and co-creation as walls fall down between brands and customers, as well as between competing brands. Any ‘throne pretenders’ face two challenges. One is positioning. The other is power.
Article thumbnail
February 10, 2016
Brand Strategy is a Reference Point for Business
However fast the world seems to be changing, some things don’t, actually. Stefan Liute discusses how brand strategy acts as a point of reference among this maelstrom of change and keeps businesses on a steady path.
Transform Awards North America trophy
October 28, 2015
Storience Wins Silver at Transform Awards North America
Branding agency Storience wins Silver at Transform Awards North America with its first client in the US, iMedicare.
An Argument Against Everybody thumbnail
February 13, 2015
An Argument Against Everybody
If everybody had a say in everything around them, what do you think the world would look like? Would we still have running water? Or broadband internet? Or straight, level roads for driving a hundred miles per hour?